Identify the kind of source
Evidence for a structured query typically includes the queried object, period, filters and aggregation. Evidence from a document includes its title, version and page or section. A business metric also needs a definition and an applicable scope. A generic source label does not tell the reader which of these checks they can perform.
A figure from an earlier report may be a snapshot taken when that report was produced. For a fresh query, check when the underlying source was last updated. A historical report and a live database may represent different points in time.
Ask four questions
- Does the source actually contain the cited fact? Open the original passage or detailed records to check.
- Do the period, units, currency and organizational scope match the question?
- Does the answer mix observed facts, calculated results and recommendations? Label them separately.
- Do missing data or an unconfirmed definition affect the conclusion? Gather the missing material before making a decision if necessary.
How one name can produce two figures
In a synthetic example, “revenue” could be grouped by the date an order was confirmed or the date payment was received. Both queries could be correct and return different values. Choose the business definition first, then align the filters to it.
| Dimension to check | What to record |
|---|---|
| Period | Calendar month or business cycle, and whether the period is complete |
| Amount definition | Order, invoice or payment amount, and tax treatment |
| Record status | Treatment of cancellations, refunds and reversals |
| Verification trail | Source location and data version at the time of generation |
When a citation will not open
Record the citation location and the time of the issue. Check permissions, whether the file moved or was deleted, whether the index refreshed and whether the document version changed. You may retain the existing summary, but label the citation as currently unverifiable until the source can be checked.
When reporting an issue, include the smallest relevant excerpt and a synthetic example that reproduces it. A complete customer file or business export is rarely an appropriate default attachment.
